Josh Marsden, whom host Eric Berman introduces as an e-commerce expert with over $100 million in sales since 2013, backed into entrepreneurship after a manager at Infusionsoft fired him. In this conversation, Josh explains how he grew from Infusionsoft services into a digital marketing agency, created the ARM5 formula with the help of a coach, and then stopped selling agency services in 2022 to start buying e-commerce brands. He shares the highs of building a portfolio that reached $7.8 million in top-line revenue and the hard lesson that followed, when a new lead magnet that doubled conversion rates quietly cut lead-to-sale conversion 25x. Josh also walks through the checklist he uses to evaluate an e-commerce brand, how faith carried him through a difficult stretch, and the vision at an ayahuasca retreat that he believes foreshadowed the birth of his daughter, Scarlett.
In this episode, you'll discover:
- How being fired from Infusionsoft, and then turned down for a schedule that let him pick up his son, pushed Josh into building his own business
- What the ARM5 formula stands for: authority, reciprocity, and monetization, plus five profit amplifiers including retention marketing
- Why Josh says the money in e-commerce is made on the back end, and how some of his brands reach a 75% customer return rate
- How a lead magnet that doubled conversion rates and halved cost per lead ended up cutting lead-to-sale conversion 25x
- The checklist Josh uses to evaluate an e-commerce brand before buying it, from tenure and profitability to diversified marketing
Episode Summary
Josh Marsden did not set out to be an entrepreneur. In early 2012 he had spent seven years at the University of Phoenix, where he was one of the top-ranked managers and had won a bunch of awards. When regulations began restricting the private education industry and limiting raises, friends at Infusionsoft convinced him to join their sales team. Talking with business owners there about how they were making money online fascinated him. At the end of 2012, after he and his second manager butted heads over management style, he was fired, even though he had been number two or three on the sales floor in October.
A month or two later, Josh took a B2B sales job, but the company had a hard time with his request to leave in time to pick up his three-year-old son from preschool a few days a week. That was the second push. He went all in on his own company in 2013, starting with Infusionsoft services before growing into a digital marketing agency focused on sales funnels and paid traffic, especially Facebook ads. He made only $74,000 that first year, but he says he loved the autonomy, including the freedom to take a noon boxing or Muay Thai class.
With help from a coach who told him his company needed a big idea, and inspired by Ryan Levesque's ASK Method, Josh created the ARM5 formula. It stands for authority, reciprocity, and monetization, plus five profit amplifiers: the persuasion matrix, testing matrix, authority engine, customer monetization, and retention marketing. Eric calls naming a process a brilliant marketing move. Josh's agency gravitated toward health and beauty, including a supplement company that saw a 1500% ROAS from Facebook advertising over six months, and Genius Network worked with his team for a year.
By 2020, Josh felt burnt out on agency services. At a mastermind retreat in San Diego, his coach told him on the hot seat that he should sell his company. Over the next two years he had five signed LOIs, sold 50% of his agency only to dissolve the deal a month and a half later, and pitched Grasshopper Bank on an e-commerce aggregator that fell apart when one partner would not sign. Seeing agency services become commoditized, and knowing agencies sell for low multiples, he stopped selling services in late 2021 and began buying e-commerce businesses in early 2022, learning from Roland Frasier.
The aggregator brought Josh the most success he had experienced as an entrepreneur. The portfolio reached $7.8 million in top-line revenue, and in December 2023 the company raised over a million dollars in capital in one month. In early 2024 he invested heavily in mentors, sponsorships, masterminds, and a dream team of marketers, with payroll reaching $175,000 a month. Then the parent company tested a new lead magnet that posted double the conversion rate and cut cost per lead by more than half. After switching over completely, results plummeted. Josh first blamed the sales team, but analytics later showed a 25x impact in lead-to-sale conversion.
Josh compares the period that followed to being knocked down 20 rounds in a row and getting back up each time, and credits his Christian faith, daily Bible reading, and prayer with carrying him through. The company lost some businesses it could no longer make payments on and is now at about $2.8 million top line, though it made the Inc. 5000 this year. He has recommitted to systems, process, and accountability with a smaller team, and now helps people buy physical product e-commerce brands. Josh closes with the story of an ayahuasca vision of a woman and a baby girl, which he believes came true when his daughter, Scarlett, was born in March 2023.
Big Ideas Discussed
Test the Whole Funnel Before Going All In
Josh's parent company had a lead magnet that had driven its success for years. When a new one posted double the conversion rate and cut cost per lead by more than half, the team switched over completely. Results plummeted. For a few months, Josh believed the sales team was failing, and he let them go before diving into the analytics himself. Comparing lead-to-sale ratios, he found a 25x impact in conversion between leads from the new lead magnet and leads from the old one.
Because that offer was supporting the e-commerce brands, the drop rippled through the business. Eric's recap for listeners is direct: when a lot of eggs sit in one basket, look carefully at the data and consider changing gradually rather than all at once. A cheaper lead is not a better lead unless it turns into a sale, and early front-end numbers can hide what happens further down the funnel.
The Money Is Made on the Back End
Josh says the biggest mistake he has seen in e-commerce for about 10 years is focusing almost entirely on the front end. Brands work hard to acquire customers, then struggle with follow-up. Helping clients generate more results from their list and existing customers was a core value proposition for his agency, because it raises both ROAS and lifetime value.
Today, some brands in his portfolio reach a 75% customer return rate, which he calls pretty much unheard of in e-commerce. Eric adds that the idea sounds obvious, yet many businesses chase a break-even first month and plan to fix the leaky bucket later. Fixing messaging, follow-through, and email after the lead comes in is where more of the success lives. Retention marketing is also one of the five profit amplifiers in Josh's ARM5 formula, a sign of how central the back end is to the way he builds and evaluates brands. When Josh later lists what he wants in a brand he might buy, a strong customer return rate is near the top.
Great Hires Still Need Systems
With cash on hand in early 2024, Josh built what he thought of as a basketball dream team of strong internet marketers and e-commerce talent, expecting them to create the processes and structure a bigger company needed. Payroll climbed to $175,000 a month. When revenue fell, that monthly commitment did not go away, and the pressure grew quickly.
His lesson is that even all-star talent needs systems, process, structure, reporting, and detailed accountability. He is now rebuilding with a smaller team and a renewed focus on culture and operations. Eric connects this to his own analogy about delegation: never get in the car alone, let a new hire drive while you sit in the passenger seat, and do not get out of the car too fast. Josh agrees that delegation is a muscle he built through books, mentors, and constant practice. He still catches himself starting work he should hand off, and reminds himself that he has people for a reason.
What Josh Looks for in an E-Commerce Acquisition
Josh notes that goals differ for every buyer, but for e-commerce brands he has a clear checklist. He looks for a brand that is tenured, where more years are better, and predictable, with no negative net profit months over the last 12 months. Ideally, revenue is turnkey, with a strong customer return rate and possibly a subscription offer with a good base of subscribers.
He also wants a diversified marketing strategy, with a few ad channels running plus strong influencer marketing and brand building that bring in organic traffic, and an industry with plenty of room to grow. His own portfolio focuses on health and beauty. Eric observes from what he has learned through Roland Frasier that many owners are burnt out and miss obvious opportunities, which is why someone who can fix what is wrong can find real value. Josh's company now helps others find and buy physical product e-commerce brands using its due diligence process.
Questions We Answer in This Episode
Who is Josh Marsden?
Josh Marsden is an e-commerce entrepreneur and acquirer whom Eric Berman introduces as having done over $100 million in sales since 2013. After working at the University of Phoenix and Infusionsoft, he built a digital marketing agency, created the ARM5 formula, and in 2022 began buying e-commerce brands. He lives in Scottsdale and is part of the Speakeasy community.
What is the ARM5 formula?
Josh Marsden explains that the ARM5 formula stands for authority, reciprocity, and monetization, followed by five profit amplifiers: the persuasion matrix, testing matrix, authority engine, customer monetization, and retention marketing. It helps companies become authorities in their industries, create reciprocity through lead magnets and content, and then monetize. Josh created it with help from a coach and was inspired by Ryan Levesque's ASK Method.
How did getting fired lead Josh Marsden to start his own business?
Josh Marsden was fired from Infusionsoft at the end of 2012 after butting heads with his manager, even though he ranked near the top of the sales floor. A later sales job struggled with his need to pick up his three-year-old son from preschool. That second push led him to go all in on his own company in 2013.
How can a better-performing lead magnet hurt sales?
Josh Marsden's company switched to a new lead magnet that doubled conversion rates and cut cost per lead by more than half. Results then plummeted. After analyzing lead-to-sale ratios, Josh found a 25x impact in conversion between leads from the new and old lead magnets, showing that cheaper leads were not turning into sales.
Why does Josh Marsden say the money in e-commerce is made on the back end?
Josh Marsden says e-commerce brands often focus on the front end and struggle with follow-up, a mistake he has seen for about 10 years. Generating more results from existing customers raises ROAS and lifetime value. Some brands in his portfolio reach a 75% customer return rate, which he calls pretty much unheard of in e-commerce.
What does Josh Marsden look for when buying an e-commerce brand?
Josh Marsden looks for a tenured, predictable brand with no negative net profit months over the last 12 months. He prefers a strong customer return rate, possibly a subscription offer, diversified marketing with several ad channels plus influencer marketing and organic traffic, and an industry with strong growth potential. His own portfolio focuses on health and beauty brands.
Why did Josh Marsden move from running an agency to buying businesses?
Josh Marsden felt burnt out on agency services by 2020 and saw the agency space becoming commoditized. He also believed services do not build wealth, since agencies often sell for low multiples. He stopped selling agency services in late 2021 and began buying e-commerce businesses in early 2022, learning from Roland Frasier. His company now also helps others buy physical product e-commerce brands.
Full Episode Transcript
Read the Full Episode Transcript
Cold Open: The Lead Magnet Switch That Sent Results Plummeting
Josh Marsden: We had great results in our parent company. And the offer we had in our parent company up to that point, that was driving us, supporting us, giving us a leg to stand on with our e-comm brands if needed. And then we made one change to our marketing. We tested a new lead magnet versus the old lead magnet that had propelled us to success for years. And that new lead magnet posted a double conversion rate. It cut cost per lead more than half. And so we were like, okay, we need to switch the lead magnet out. Focus on just using this lead magnet. And. And we did. And then we just saw our results plummet.
Eric Berman: Welcome to the Speakeasy Podcast, where the real conversations happen behind closed doors with the boldest entrepreneurs, creators, and growth minds in the game. No fluff, no filters. Just the raw strategies, personal stories, and mental models that move the needle. I'm Eric Berman. Now let's get into it.
Meet Josh Marsden, E-Commerce Operator and Acquirer
Eric Berman: In today's episode of Inside the Speakeasy Podcast, I'm so excited to bring on Josh Marsden, an incredible ecom guru expert, having done over $100 million in sales since 2013, created the ARM5 formula of success for growing any business, any commerce brands, and has then since become an expert at finding, buying, and selling e-commerce brands, and has an incredible entrepreneurial story of how what's worked, what doesn't work, they've gone from huge growth to downsizing and all the things we all go through. And you're going to learn some incredible entrepreneurial lessons. Plus, he shares a very cool personal story after a little sip of ayahuasca. So get ready to hear that. So welcome to Inside the Speakeasy. Welcome, Josh.
Josh Marsden: Yeah, thanks for having me, Eric.
Eric Berman: Yeah, my pleasure. All right, let's dig in. So, you know, being a recovering, I should say I was surviving, maybe a surviving recovering agency addict, you know, person myself. You went through that. And typically agency owners don't like, hey, what do you want to grow up? And, you know, what do you want to be when you grow up? An agency owner. Like, let's take me through the beginning a little bit. Like, how did you get into e-comm in the first place?
From University of Phoenix to Getting Fired at Infusionsoft
Josh Marsden: Yeah, yeah, sure. So Infusionsoft. I have to thank for that. So back in early 2012, I was at a Fortune 500 company here in Phoenix called University of Phoenix. I had been there for seven years. I was fairly successful. I was one of the top ranked managers in the whole company. Won a bunch of awards. And then I decided to switch careers because the private education industry was getting hit by Obama's regulations, and it was restricting our business and how we can grow and how we could even do our job as managers even. And it was affecting our ability to get raises. So I was just at a point where I was open to other potential opportunities. And I had some friends that were at Infusionsoft. They kind of sold me on coming over and selling at Infusionsoft. And I was. I was a manager at University of Phoenix, so. So I basically kind of took a responsibility, step down when I went to Infusionsoft. But it was at Infusionsoft that I was on the phone with different business owners and hearing all these crazy ideas of how they're making money online, and I was just like, blown away. I was blown away and just fascinated. And then after, at the end of 2012, my second manager at Infusionsoft, him and I kind of subtly butted heads a little bit, and he decided to fire me, which was a blessing in disguise at the time.
Eric Berman: You're, like, totally pissed off, emotional, like, what's going on?
Josh Marsden: Yeah, I mean, I was like, I was number two or three on the sales floor in October, and he let me go, like, around December 10th.
Eric Berman: And he's probably worried you're gonna take his job.
Josh Marsden: Yeah, possibly. I mean, like, I didn't agree with his management style. Got it. And I didn't tell him directly, and I wasn't disrespectful, but I think he can tell through my body language. And also just doing the activities he wanted us to do. Like, for example, he was the type of guy that his team had to be disciples. And if he wanted to go to lunch with everybody, you stopped everything. You went to lunch because you just want to hear everything he says. And I just didn't agree with that. I was the type of person who was like, hey, I want to plug in. I want to get the job done. I want to get results. That's all I care about. That's what I care about the most. And, you know, we just in mesh. And so he, you know, let me go. And it was a blessing in disguise. And that's really, like, the kick that got me starting my company. And then.
Eric Berman: And it's interesting because, you know, as you say this, you weren't initially like, hey, I'm just going to go out of college and just do the whole figure out and just start some widget idea. I had. You started in the sales side and said, wait a second. You backed into being an entrepreneur?
Josh Marsden: Yep. Yeah. No, for sure. Actually, you know, I was really backed into becoming an entrepreneur. Like maybe a month or so after that, after doing freelance work for maybe two months and just barely making enough to kind of get by, I started at another company. And this company, it was a sales job. Again, it was a B2B sales job where you had to actually go out and build relationships with people, knock on office doors and talk to, you know, owners, managers, etc. They wanted me to work 7am to 7pm I told them that I had a 3 year old son. I had to pick him up from preschool at 5:30, two to three days a week. You know, it wasn't like a big ask, but they had a hard time with it because they had a culture expectation. And so that was really like the second push, you know, the second kick in the pants to say, you know what? I'm going all in on building my business and the rest is history. So that's really how I got started. I started my company as an agency. I didn't quite know what I was doing back in 2013. I just knew that I, you know, was all in on it. And I was. I believed in myself and I knew that I can do it. And I really just focused at the time on Infusionsoft services, you know, just helping people implement and run Infusionsoft. And then I. From there, I kind of grew into a digital marketing agency, focusing on sales funnels, focusing on paid traffic, Facebook ads especially. And then we became the ARM5 Formula company, you know, several years after that.
Eric Berman: Nice. Okay, so you started Infusionsoft. You just led that transition, by the way. I'm sure at this point, if nothing else, you know, maybe you're not making the money out of the gates, but you're like, damn, I don't have an ass manager to deal with. So you're way happier. You're already running ahead. In the beginning once, you're just like, okay, I'm happier. I remember those times as an entrepreneur, you're like, I might not be making it yet, but I'm actually enjoying it. Because you're responsible for your own, you know, I'm talking about [unclear]. You feel the own responsibility. It's a different feeling totally, man.
Josh Marsden: I mean, that first year I made only 74,000 bucks. I didn't make that much money, but I definitely enjoyed the autonomy. I enjoyed, you know, being reliant on myself, having my own schedule. You know, I used to be in boxing, Muay Thai and a little jiu jitsu even. And it was great, you know. Cause I could just go take a noon class, go back to work afterwards, you know, and it was awesome. I enjoyed those little things, you know, back then, but man, you know, things have changed a lot since then, you know, 74,000 a year. Well, that was a long time ago now.
Eric Berman: Nice. I love it.
Naming a Process: Building the ARM5 Formula
Eric Berman: All right, so you just mentioned it. I'm going to bring it back. Kudos for naming. We always talk about our companies. If you can name a process, that's always a win, in fact always, you know, it always increases the value of your company. We have a process, you have the ARM5 formula. Sounds badass and cool. Let's talk about it. What are the ARM5 formula?
Josh Marsden: Yeah, I appreciate it, man. I had a really good coach that helped me craft it. Ali Bilson, who I definitely recommend to anybody that wants a really good coach that's direct and very, you know, business savvy. Something about British people, man. Like I have a few British friends and just really. Business savvy. Yeah. You know, it must be baked into their education and we just don't even know what happens.
Eric Berman: All the tea gets them focused probably.
Josh Marsden: But yeah, he helped me create the ARM5 formula. He just, he said I needed a big idea. I need a big idea in my company. And so I was a bit inspired by Ryan Levesque, who is actually my business coach now even. And I worked with him years ago too, back in 2016 for a year in his mastermind. I was kind of inspired by what he did with the ASK Method when I was creating the ARM5 formula. And Ali, you know, again was a great advisor guide on helping me craft this. And, you know, it stands for authority, reciprocity and monetization and then the five profit amplifiers. And so basically what it comes down to is it comes down to when we work with companies, in the past it was clients, now it's our own. We help these companies become authorities in the industries that they're in. We help them create reciprocity through the value that they put out in the market, through lead magnets, through content. And then we monetize, you know, as simply that.
Eric Berman: Got it.
Josh Marsden: And what's the five profit amplifiers persuasion matrix, testing matrix, the authority engine, customer monetization, and then it's the retention marketing.
Eric Berman: Got it. And I gotta say, like again, for anybody listening, and I know I kind of just brushed on it, but I think it's such a brilliant marketing move to coin a process. And you know, we all do a lot of similar things as agency owners, but to actually coin a process and then draw, you know, I've been to your website and you have a really cool visual that shows it. It really makes it seem. And I'm not saying what you're doing wasn't special, but it just creates that image and it's a really smart thing to do, if nothing else.
Health and Beauty Brands and Client Results in E-Commerce
Eric Berman: Okay, so you're running that, you're getting clients and you're doing, you know, you became this, you know, amazing e-commerce guru and then, you know, tell me about the success and some of the things I know. You've done over a hundred million dollars, you did over 100 million in revenue on e-comm. Is there a niche within niche in e-comm? And then I'm going to lead into. We're going to talk a lot about your acquiring e-comm companies as a way to grow, which is fascinating.
Josh Marsden: Yeah, for sure. I mean, you know, we focus on just physical product. e-comm. We didn't have like a niche, like an industry necessarily, but we definitely seem to gravitate quite, quite a bit towards health and beauty. And even today, like our portfolio is health and beauty and we're only focused on buying health and beauty brands, you know, for example. But back then, you know, as an agency, I mean, it was like supplements, for example, we had a lot of success with supplements. Like, we had one company that saw like a 1500% ROAS from Facebook advertising over six months. They saw a significant, you know, result there and they grew up, I believe, by like 2.6 times versus the previous 12 months before. They worked with us, for example. And that was just one example. But, you know, we worked with even companies like Genius Network, Like Genius Network worked with us for a year and we beat their previous advertising results. And they worked with Nicholas Kusmich, who is a very respected, you know, online marketing and advertising expert. But we were able to beat his results with our results, which is nice. So we worked with like a lot of e-comm brands, e-comm businesses and, you know, as long as we were set up with the right client and we definitely got great results.
Eric Berman: Got it.
Why the Money Is Made on the Back End
Eric Berman: So you got a lot of results. And if I'm here listening, can you share like, what are. I mean, because you're still doing that now today, you're obviously acquiring companies and then you're adding your magic sauce in there. What are a couple maybe tips or techniques you can share? Like that's helping you really win.
Josh Marsden: Yeah. You know, today it's like, you know, my hat has shifted quite a bit. You know, back then I was obviously much more of a hands on marketer because, you know, smaller team, you know, smaller business, doing more of the marketing. Today I'm more of a director if anything. So I'm really good at being able to like see a business and see the holes, see the gaps and then delegate that stuff and then hold the team accountable and make sure that we're making those shifts, we're getting things done and we're making those impacts. So I wouldn't say like there's like this, you know, crazy strategy or anything that I'm doing today. I'm just, I'm a CEO more so today than ever. But you know, just to give you maybe some feedback, like we've got some companies in our portfolio right now. They're literally at like a 75% customer return rate, which is pretty much unheard of in e-comm is typically struggle with the follow up and they typically are very front focused. And that's a big mistake that I've seen for probably 10 years in e-comm. That was a big value proposition we had whenever we worked with e-comm businesses was helping them on the back end generate more results from their list from their customers. This way they can see their ROAS and their lifetime value go up.
Eric Berman: So the mistake that you're saying, the mistake to avoid is focusing so much on just the general acquisition and then saying, okay, let me just put [unclear] 80/20 into that versus wait a second, how do you nurture them? How do you make sure they have a great experience so they'll refer others, et cetera.
Josh Marsden: Yeah, totally, man. Yeah, totally. I mean the money's made on the back end, you know, that's the bottom line.
Eric Berman: Yep, yep. You get, you work so hard to get the lead. I hear that so, so much. And it seems, it's such an. I think it's one of those things you say and it seems so obvious, but it is incredible how many times people miss it because it's just like, get that ROAS, get that, you know, first month, you know, break even, you know, kind of thing. And you're like, yeah, we'll just fix it back here and fix the leaky bucket. Once you get the lead, you're going to have more success, right? Fix your messaging, fix your follow through. Are you emailing them correctly? You're asking for, you know, all that.
Learning to Delegate and Give Up Control
Eric Berman: That's great. Okay, so you had a lot of success over the years with I assume following your own formula, your own system that you're building out now. I get it. You built up and you've done what a lot of us entrepreneurs have a hard time doing, which is delegating and bringing out a team and getting out of your own way. Was that tough to do? Was it hard for you to like, figure out how to build systems and not control? A lot of us have that problems.
Josh Marsden: It is still hard, you know, it's still hard. I think with me is just, you know, I had a lot of challenges in trusting people and communicating the right way and not trying to do the work myself because I've heard this from colleagues even that are having the challenge of growing, you know, their business and growing their staff and delegating more. We always feel like we can do things faster. And it's true, you know, we probably could. But, you know, at the same time you have to know the value of your time and you have to stay in your lane and focus on your 80/20 with your, you know, special sauce, your, you know, special skills that you can apply to a business to grow a business much faster. And so, you know, I don't know if that answers your question, but that's what I kind of struggle with over the years when I started to expand and started to have a team and even now, like, you know, I have to be like, I have to hold myself back a bit and something I've always kind of.
Eric Berman: What's, I mean, what's [unclear]? I mean, what got you to finally over. Over the hurdle of saying I got to give up control? Like, what was the. Do you remember? Or is it just a mental shift at some point that happened? Or was it just sheer like volume of work that you didn't have a choice?
Josh Marsden: Yeah, I mean, all the above. I think it's a, it's a muscle, you know, it's a muscle. When you start using it, you get better and better at using it. And it was a lot of books, a lot of education, you know, a lot of advisement from different mentors over the years too. You know, I feel like I've reprogrammed myself, you know, over the last 10 plus years. I read lots of material that it really is all about being super efficient with your time and knowing the value of your time and knowing how to maximize your impact on your business by using, you know, that framework. You know, all that stuff has been basically like now over the last several years kind of in my DNA almost. So I mean, I've got books and things like that I could definitely recommend to help someone if they're struggling with, you know, making that transition where they can really like almost reprogram themselves, like I have. Because now, I mean, I'm, like, super vigilant with my time and very efficient, very organized, you know, with my schedule. And I delegate like crazy and follow up, hold people accountable. And I'm very conscious of not putting, like, time into stuff that I shouldn't, you know, because sometimes, you know, I'm sure you feel this too.
Eric Berman: You.
Josh Marsden: You have this impulse like, I want to do this or I want to work on this, you know, or you just start doing it, and then you're like, wait, wait, this isn't the best use of my time right now. I have people for a reason. Let me delegate this out, you know, And I catch myself when that happens.
Eric Berman: Yeah, no, I think for me, it's definitely the Dan Sullivan Who Not How and just that philosophy, which I think I've had on. I always say, like analogy I always use is never get in the car alone. If you're going to take the wheel, somebody's got to be in the pat. In the passenger seat watching immediately. Otherwise you're never going to get out of the car. So, like, take the wheel first, second time you're driving, let them take the wheel, and you sit in the passenger seat. And then. The mistake I often make is getting out of the car too fast. All right, I hired somebody. They should be getting out. Here you go, here's the car. Have fun. And then you're like, oh, shit, it just crashed. I wonder why I try to get out of there too fast.
Burnout, Five LOIs, and the Pivot to Buying Businesses
Eric Berman: All right, let's move over into. I want to talk about the real exciting stuff from. What I wanted to learn from you is on the acquisition side, you have a commerce agency, you're doing really well, these brands, and all of a sudden something triggers and you say, well, wait a second, maybe I should start buying these companies rolling up. What's. What happened and where are we at today?
Josh Marsden: Sure. Yeah. So going into 2020, I was definitely, like, at a point where I felt a little bit burnt out on agency services. And so I remember I was at a mastermind retreat with Ali Bilson, who I mentioned in San Diego, early 2020, before COVID. He put me on the hot seat, and I told him, you know, what challenges I was having in my company. And what he told me, I did not expect. He came back and he told me on the hot seat, you should sell your company. And I was like, it's like, oh, okay. And so that was really, like, kind of what started. It started the transition. So from early 2020 until late 2021, I had five different LOIs. To buy my business that were signed. And in 2020, I had three, and I really thought the third one was going to go through. And then he completely ghosted me, like a few days before my birthday, which is Halloween. And then that fell through, obviously, and. And then 2021, I did sell my agency, 50% of it, to someone in early 2021. And then a month and a half into it, we had to dissolve it because we just had misaligned expectations. He didn't realize that we would have to hold on to our clients and that would also take up our bandwidth in order to continue to produce capital and support ourselves. It's like he didn't come in with the expectation that I have to really invest money into this to make this transition, because he had his own e-comm brands that he wanted us to focus on, to help him grow those brands to become, you know, much more valuable brands. But he wasn't willing to really go all in is, I think, what happened there. And so we amicably dissolved it. And then at the end of 2021, I was partnering up with three other people and we even went to New York City, made a big pitch to Grasshopper Bank about building an e-comm aggregator with a software component, actually a few software components building like an e-comm ecosystem, basically. And. And they loved it, and they said, yes, we're in. But then 30 days later, January 2022, one of those guys, out of the four, he wouldn't sign papers to sell his business to the lead of the four. And I was, you know, one of the four. And so, you know, I saw that whole thing kind of falling apart. And luckily I had started to be proactive and started to shift my wheels, so to speak, into buying e-comm businesses myself versus depending on this. This opportunity, this initiative that we were putting together. So I knew for a while that I wanted to get out of the agency space because I saw it being just commoditized, you know, unfortunately, you know, Russell Brunson, I think, is to thank for this. No knock on him. He's a great marketer, but, you know, he was marketing how easy it was to make money online at one point to get people on ClickFunnels. And I think that it caused a lot of people to think that they sell marketing services and then deliver results when they didn't have experience. And that and some other things I just saw, like, the agency space just getting commoditized. And I also knew that you can't build wealth selling services. Yeah, you just in a multiple 2 on an agency is like 1.5. It's not very high. And so you can't, you know, you came and sell your agency for a good multiple unless you're like 10 million plus a year.
Eric Berman: That's right.
Josh Marsden: A lot of work and takes a lot of time as an operational nightmare, basically. So, you know, all that kind of led to me making the big pivot going into 2022 and, you know, not selling services anymore. The last time I sold agency services was late 2021, and I just started buying businesses in early 2022. Just learning from Roland Frasier and what he teaches people. The rest is history.
Eric Berman: Yep. Yeah, no, it's brilliant. Roland, one of our initial founding San Diego members back in the day, Speakeasy and others. But yeah, no, he's awesome. Love what they teach over at EPIC Network now. And in fact, one skill that I regret not having learned more of and I always go back and say if my current sort of projects don't go well, I'm going to go see Roland and go deep into his projects. So you got ahead of me there. Fantastic. So you learn again through, you know, what Roland teaches and others, how to really find the right deal, how to negotiate, get the right value, acquire and buy for very little money down kind of thing is that you follow a lot of the playbook that he teaches?
Josh Marsden: Yeah, no, no, for sure. I mean, I got to know it very intimately. His lead coach in 2022 is a good friend of mine, Adam Lyons. He's no longer working with Roland, but he helped me out a lot, too. Gave me lots of guidance, lots of feedback at times. But yeah, I just, you know, I'm a student first and foremost. You know, when I focus on learning something, I just, I go all in and I consume, you know, [unclear]. So this way I can, you know, grow and, you know, learn a skill that I'm trying to skill.
Building a Dream Team and a $175,000 Monthly Payroll
Eric Berman: So let's jump ahead. So, I mean, you immerse yourself in that you learned some incredible skills on the acquisition side. And how's it going? Like, where are we at today? Like, what are maybe of all those things you learned, what would be maybe the top, you know, one or two things. You're like, oh, my God, this is the biggest thing that I think has helped is, you know, looking back on.
Josh Marsden: Yeah, man, it's gone. Overall, you know, well, you know, three and a half years now, you know, we've been an e-commerce aggregator and we've had the most success I've ever experienced as an entrepreneur due to that. And, you know, I'm blessed to say that, you know, we've had some phenomenal investors that have really supported us and believed in our vision. And, you know, we grew a portfolio up to it was like just under 10 million. It was at 7.8 million at one point. Then, you know, I learned a lot of lessons early last year. So we had a high in December 2023, where we raised over a million capital just in one month. We had a good portfolio and it was putting up good numbers. And I had. I really had invested into getting a really solid team. I kind of had. I was inspired by the basketball dream team. You know, I'm a big basketball fan, and I wanted to bring in really good Internet marketers and new e-comm. And that's what I had focused on up to that point. And then in early 2024, you know, I had more cash than I've ever had to be able to invest in my company. And I was really doubling down on us getting to our milestone for 2024. And so I invested into mentors, sponsorships, mastermind groups, people, you know, got payroll, was all the way up to 175,000 a month. And I thought I was doing, you know, all the things you're supposed to do to go where you're at. You know, I was almost at eight figures to eight figures and beyond. But what I didn't realize is that the pendulum swings very fast when you have that much cash and capital needs. If your engine, you know, if you are a cash flow business, you know, fails and you're living play by play well, you know, it can affect the entire business.
Eric Berman: And that monthly note doesn't just disappear when cash is down one month, it still sits there.
Josh Marsden: Yeah. Yep. For sure.
The Lead Magnet Test That Cut Sales Conversion 25x
Josh Marsden: So that's what happened, is that we had so great results in our parent company. And the offer we had in our parent company up to that point, that was driving us, supporting us, giving us a leg to stand on with our e-comm brands if needed. And then we made one change to our marketing. We tested a new lead magnet versus the old lead magnet that had propelled us to success for years. And that new lead magnet posted a double conversion rate. It cut cost per lead more than half. And so we were like, okay, we need to switch the lead magnet out. Focus on just using this lead magnet. And we did. And then we just saw our results plummet. But. And we didn't know. We didn't think it was that. You know, I thought it was the sales team failing honestly for a few months. And then after I let go of the sales team and I dove into the marketing and I, you know, did some analytics and identified our lead to sale ratio with new leads coming in from the new lead magnet versus the old lead magnet. I saw that there was a 25x impact in conversion, and that was why basically we weren't seeing the same level of results. Yeah.
Eric Berman: So it's a lesson there to kind of recap for those listening. It's interesting, you know, when you have a lot of eggs in one basket, and if you're gonna make the full switch, you better damn look at your data and be careful and maybe not go all in right away. You know, slowly, gradually. And it sounds like you had enough data out of the gates based on that first test. And you're saying, okay, this is it. Let's get excited, let's go all in. And just. And you went, look, I'd made that mistake. I think a lot of us made that mistake. So it's went from feeling really good about yourself, feeling like you're gonna make it, and then you go the other way. So how does that happen emotionally? And how have you swung back out of that, man?
Josh Marsden: So I've used this metaphor quite a bit as I've explained this. It felt like being a boxer in a boxing ring and being knocked down 20 rounds in a row and just getting back up and continuing to fight. And it still feels that way. So, you know, mentally, it definitely has been, you know, challenging at times. You know, luckily, you know, I've stayed true to my Christianity. I have a great relationship with God. I read the Bible every morning, you know, pray every morning. And, you know, that strength of spirit, strength of will has really been what's helped me get through this, to be quite honest. So, you know, that's how I've been able to kind of get through this storm step by step. So, yeah, that's the best advice I can give anybody.
Rebuilding With Systems, Process, and Accountability
Eric Berman: And how are we doing today? Like, what's been the tweak to. To get you back on track? And by the way, I heard a quote yesterday at an event. Really good. I mean, just all winners have been. Are multiple losers first. Like, you have to have lost before in order to win. Like, otherwise you're not even playing the game, which most people don't even play. And that's the journey we go through as entrepreneurs. Like, it's, you know, the more losses you have, the more, you know, the bigger the win. So kudos to you for getting back on your feet and today. So what's happened?
Josh Marsden: Yeah, I appreciate it. Yeah. So, I mean, so we still have an e-comm portfolio company. You know, we made the Inc. 5000 this year too. We've had some success but. But we have a smaller portfolio now because we lost some businesses because we couldn't make payments on those businesses because our parent company was supporting everything basically at that point. And you know, we're kind of in a. We're in a rebuilding place, honestly. And we're also, we're slightly pivoting. We're going to be an e-comm aggregator. We're not changing that. But yeah, we're just pivoting our strategy basically because of the loss of momentum, because of the decrease in revenue because we're at like 2.8 million now. Top line. We were at 7.8 at one point. So we've lost a lot. We've now kind of shifted our strategy quite a bit. Like we've got a much smaller team. I'm not committed to 175,000 per month in payroll, thank God, because that was a lot of stress and a lot of pressure. I'm recommitted to culture building systems operations because my previous kind of mindset and thought process there was to bring in best of the best type people and they could help create that process, that system, that structure with a bigger team and, and it just, that doesn't work. They still need systems, process, structure, reporting accountability in detail, you know. So I'm really like honing in on that right now, working on that a lot. There's definitely some growing pains there for sure.
Eric Berman: That's a great lesson. I want to make sure to restate. Again for those listening, you know, just because they're amazing on paper, look like all stars, doesn't necessarily mean they're going to be an all star on your team, within your system. And sometimes we think we're just going to hire our way out into success with the right people and it they, you know, and like I said. All right, here you go. I'm going to get out of the car. Good luck.
What to Look for When Buying an E-Commerce Brand
Eric Berman: Go drive. And going back to what you said earlier and again, I'd love to get a, maybe a takeaway from you on the acquisition side. You know, clearly you like that strategy. You're going out there. Is there something that, for those of us that, that are maybe thinking about doing that or been interested in that, you know, any tips for like how to start or what to look for like in a company, if you're going to maybe acquire them.
Josh Marsden: Yeah, it's kind of a broad question, but you know, I would just say that, you know, everybody has different goals when it comes to buying a business. You know, like if you're buying a business, it could be I want to expand my agency so I'm gonna buy another agency. Or it could be, you know, I'm gonna buy brands that I could put all my knowledge and strategies and team into. This way I have more assets, you know, for example, it just really depends, you know.
Eric Berman: So I'm thinking more on the commerce side. Like if you're looking at an e-comm company.
Josh Marsden: Yep. Yeah. I mean I would just try to find a brands that is tenured. More years the better. Predictable, obviously no negative net profit months over the last 12 months. Ideally super turnkey on revenue, meaning that they have a really solid customer return rate. Subscription offer possibly as well with a good subscribed base of customers. Diversified marketing strategy. So they maybe they have a few ad channels running. Plus they do a great job with influencer marketing and building brands. This way there's organic traffic. And then, you know, in a industry that has a lot of potential for growth, you know, that's what I would look for and that's what I always look for, you know, first and foremost when it comes to buying a business.
Eric Berman: So you have your own little checklist that sounds like you just write off six or seven good little things there. They sort of have to all hit those items and then, okay, now let's talk. And then obviously, what's the price? Where's the owner at? And from what I learned, just hearing Roland and others, it's just so surprising at how many people are just burnt out on the business. You know, just let me go out and you run the thing and I'm happy to, you know, take a check or you know, pay me a little bit along the way. I bet you find a lot of that, right? Or they just opportunities that they're missing that you're like, there's 10 things you could do here you're not even doing, you're still making money. Like I said, that's a skill. I wish I, you know, intuitively understand it having seen some of the, you know, programs that Roland teaches and others. And I'm like, damn, there's such big opportunity for people that, let me say a different way. It's amazing how many people are doing so well in different businesses despite doing a lot of wrong things. And if you can go in there and fix them, it's just like wow. Right. Anything else that I didn't ask you with respect to the business side on some of the cool commerce stuff you're doing and others.
Josh Marsden: Yeah, I mean, you know, I'd love to highlight how we're now helping people find and buy their own e-comm businesses.
Eric Berman: Oh, cool.
Josh Marsden: So it definitely was inspired by Roland. We're just niching down. We're focusing on helping people buy physical product, e-comm brands. And, you know, so far it's gone really well. And I believe in our process. We've got a great rigorous due diligence process and, you know, a lot that we put into just our acquisition department over the last several years and also a lot of lessons too that we've had.
Eric Berman: Oh yeah. I mean, we've been through it, so that's outstanding. So you took the skills that you guys did to acquire over the last few years and said, all right, let's now teach that method, which your spin off version of what you've learned and kind of adding your own magic sauce based on your niche. That's great. You know, definitely love to chat sometime. I think, you know, I'd be interested in that myself. Well, very cool.
An Ayahuasca Vision and the Birth of His Daughter
Eric Berman: And then before we exit the podcast, you have a very cool story that you told me in the, quote, virtual green room here. I want to talk about destiny. You had a cool story about how you have your youngest. Tell me that story.
Josh Marsden: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Scarlett, my two year old daughter. So, yeah, so back in 2020, I was intrigued by drinking ayahuasca. And I remember I was dating a girl the first five months of 2020 and we both were very open minded about ayahuasca and that we talked about it and we both wanted to try it. And then I remember after we stopped dating, I got offered the opportunity to go to a retreat in Southern California and to drink ayahuasca. And I, I didn't even hesitate. I said, sure, sign me up, you know, and I signed up right away and, and then I went. And then, you know, I, I went through, you know, the experience of going to, you know, this retreat. It was like maybe about 10, 15 people at an Airbnb pretty nice house. And it was a lot of preparation going into it. You know, you, you have to eat a specific diet. You can't drink alcohol 10 days prior or something like that. You know, there was all these conditions that you had to meet before you went in there. And then you go in there and, you know, they prep you for the evening when you're gonna start drinking and you can't eat anything all day, so you have to do it kind of like on an empty stomach. And then they have their ceremony, and it's led by a shaman, and there's music playing, and, you know, he goes through his procedure, and then we all drink however much we chose to drink. And I remember the person that introduced me to this connection told me, drink a full cup. I'm like, okay. So when it was my time to get my cup and they asked how much, I said, full cup, and I got a full cup. So I have a full cup in my hand, and I remember, like, you know, holding it up and then drinking it. Everybody drinking at the same time, and it tastes like barbecue sauce. And then all of a sudden, I just wait. I know it's. Something's gonna happen.
Eric Berman: Yeah. Yeah.
Josh Marsden: What's gonna happen? I'm just like, okay. Because, you know, and then it just hits me, and it starts hitting me, and everything just slows down. And I look around, and people near me are like, you know, really slow, and then they start vomiting, even. And, you know, it just. And it's really. It feels, like, really loud and scary. And my anxiety is growing, and my nausea is there also at the same time. And I'm like, I hate throwing up. I don't want to throw up. And so, you know, I luckily do not, as they call it, purge, which is throw up. But I pretty much get myself into a ball and just hold it all in, the nausea. And I go through my thoughts, and I remember, like, the next few hours as I'm experiencing this, it was literally like. Like walking into the spirit world and seeing different things. And one of the things that I saw was I saw a vision of me with a woman and a baby girl. And I remember when I saw it, I cried, and I was like, I didn't know what it meant. I thought maybe it meant the girl that I just had feelings for, but it didn't. And it was basically a vision of the future. And then fast forward to early 2021. I meet my girl, my fiance, and then, you know, in mid-2022, she gets pregnant. And then in March 2023, we have Scarlett. So, you know, it's just crazy how, you know, life works out. It's as if God had this plan, and he was showing me his plan.
Eric Berman: I love it. Now, what did you tie the two together when you're like, okay, this was my dream? Like, did that just, like, when she got pregnant or after you just knew you had a girl or what was the.
Josh Marsden: Oh, Yeah, I mean, it was definitely after she got pregnant. Like, you know, it's funny because, you know, she got pregnant, and prior to that, we were talking about, like, I want another kid. I'd like to experience another kid. And I told her about the, you know, what happened with ayahuasca and whatnot. And then, you know, we went through, you know, we went to the doctor, found out she was pregnant, and then leading up to us finding out the gender, I remember, you know, she went through her tests, got an envelope, and then we went into the car where she opened the envelope with the gender reveal, and then we saw it was going to be a girl. And I was like, wow, this is crazy.
Eric Berman: Come on. You knew it was going to be a girl. You didn't even have to open the envelope, right? You're like.
Josh Marsden: But you're still in disbelief, you know, because, you know, that's just, you know, just crazy to think about that. You have a vision of the future, and then the future actually happens, you know, I mean. But yeah, I mean, it was definitely some powerful stuff and a powerful vision.
Joining the Speakeasy Community
Eric Berman: Well, very cool. And I guess my last question, and I haven't really been asking these, but I am more curious now as I go through, because most of our interviews are people that are in the community. When I first met you, you came to San Diego, to our San Diego chapter, and at my beloved good friend Mike Keating's house. And then you went back to Scottsdale, where you live, and then we have our amazing leader over there, Jasmine. And how's it been so far? Like, are you enjoying. And you. It sounds like you've been to a lot of different types of masterminds before. You said you invest a lot. How's your Speakeasy experience?
Josh Marsden: Yeah, no, it's been great. I mean, you know, you guys have done a great job of just growing the community fast, and, you know, there's lots of great people in the community, and it seems like everybody's got the right, you know, mindset, being a part of the community, just wanting to give and just help and support each other, which has been awesome. You know, I've met some new people. I've also, you know, reconnected with other people that I've known for a while. It's been awesome. And, yeah, I love it so far.
Eric Berman: Cool. Appreciate it. Well, we're glad to have you, and glad to have you on the podcast as well. Thank you so much for coming in today, Josh.
Josh Marsden: Yeah, thanks for having me. Appreciate it.
Eric Berman: Take care. And that's a wrap from the Speakeasy Podcast. If something sparked for you, don't keep it to yourself. Share it, review it, and pass it to the one person who needs to hear this right now. Want in on the real mastermind? Tap the link in the show notes to apply until next time. Keep scaling, stay sharp, and don't be the smartest one in the room.

About The Guest
Josh Marsden
Josh Marsden is the founder and CEO of ARM5 Formula Co., an e-commerce company that acquires and grows physical product brands and helps investors buy their own. After seven years as a manager at the University of Phoenix and a sales role at Infusionsoft, he started his own company in 2013, growing it from Infusionsoft services into a digital marketing agency focused on sales funnels and Facebook ads. He created the ARM5 formula, built around authority, reciprocity, monetization, and five profit amplifiers, and has been credited with over $100 million in e-commerce sales. Since 2022 he has run an e-commerce aggregator focused on health and beauty brands, which made the Inc. 5000. Josh holds an MBA, hosts The Build Your Wealth Show, and is a member of the Speakeasy Mastermind community in Scottsdale.


